The current landscape in gaming controllers is exceptional. The modern gamepads available for purchase now are marked by superior quality, enhanced versatility, and extensive customization options when compared to previous generations. Gamers using an Xbox Series X or Series S (or a Windows PC) have a wide array of excellent third-party options to choose from, including brands like PowerA, Scuf, Nacon, and Turtle Beach, in addition to high-caliber first-party controllers. The era of low-quality, ineffective controllers is a thing of the past.

Extensive game testing across various genres, such as first-person shooters, fighting games, action-adventure titles, racing games, and indie roguelikes, has revealed that the standard Xbox Wireless Controller remains the top choice for most users. This controller is not only ideal for Xbox gaming but also serves as an excellent PC gamepad.

While the conventional Xbox controller balances quality, comfort, versatility, and cost effectively, there are several noteworthy alternatives for those with specific needs. High-end models like the Xbox Elite Series 2 and Scuf Instinct Pro, as well as budget-friendly options such as the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller, offer viable alternatives.

Criteria for Evaluation

Connectivity: Is the controller wireless? Does it support Bluetooth? If it is wired, is the cable replaceable?

Quality: Examines the build quality and checks for any glitches or reliability issues.

Extra Features: Looks at the availability of remappable buttons and additional functionalities.

Customization: Includes the ability to remap buttons, create software profiles, and any aesthetic customization options.

Value: Considers whether the controller is affordably priced, average, or has a high premium.

The Best Xbox Controller for Most Users

The official Xbox Wireless Controller is a strong choice due to its balanced features. It includes a dedicated share button, supports Bluetooth, and is equipped with a USB-C port that can charge Microsoft’s play-and-charge rechargeable battery. Despite its affordability, the controller’s hardware is robust, with responsive sticks, buttons, triggers, and a satisfying D-pad. Though it lacks some extra customizable features found in pricier models, its legacy of iterations makes it a reliable all-around option. Moreover, user-replaceable batteries provide flexibility, allowing for the use of rechargeable AAs or battery packs.

Best Budget Option

The PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller is an economical choice for those who do not mind using a wired connection. Priced around $37.99, it features two rear mappable buttons and various color schemes, including licensed designs from popular games. The controller’s biggest drawback is its use of a microUSB connection. However, its build quality and additional features make it an excellent value.

Best Premium Controller

The Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 is a premium version of the standard controller, offering enhanced materials, extra buttons, swappable sticks and D-pad, and extensive customization options. Despite its higher price point, the added features cater to serious gamers looking for an edge. However, the Elite Series 2’s built-in rechargeable battery and superior build quality come with increased weight and cost, making it a considerable investment.

A Convenient Alternative to the Elite

The Scuf Instinct Pro offers high customization and rear rocker buttons instead of paddles. It also includes hair triggers with quick response times, making it advantageous for certain gaming preferences. Though its price starts at $199.99, its comfort and feature set may justify the expense for dedicated gamers.

The Best Customizable Controller

The RIG Nacon Revolution X stands out for its extensive customization. Priced at $99.99, it offers detailed software tweaks, customizable rear buttons, adjustable sticks, and optional weights for added heft. Targeted at users who enjoy fine-tuning their gaming hardware, this controller is a versatile option once dialed in to user preferences.

Best Controller for Shooters

The Turtle Beach Recon Controller excels in audio customization, particularly for FPS games. Features like the Superhuman Hearing mode enhance gameplay by drawing out critical sound cues. Priced around $60, it is an affordable option that provides tangible in-game advantages, alongside additional rear buttons for improved ergonomics.

Other Noteworthy Controllers

Several other controllers are worth considering for specific features or unique builds, including options from brands like GameSir, 8BitDo, Horipad, and Hyperkin. Each offers distinctive attributes that can cater to various user preferences and needs.

Photography Credit: Antonio G. Di Benedetto / The Verge

Update (September 26th): Pricing and links have been updated, and additional contributions made by Brandon Widder.

Source link